Bombay HC Judge P D Naik, ET LegalWorld | Court Practice News


The public perception of media is that it gets way too involved in publicising cases and gives its “decision” even before a matter is tried in court, but judges don’t get influenced by media, said Justice Prakash D Naik of the Bombay High Court on Saturday. He was addressing students as part of the lecture series ‘GRK-Judiciary Talks’ at G R Kare College of Law, Margao.

Responding to a question about his opinion on “media trial”, Justice Naik said, “It is always said that there is something called a media trial.”

The judge said, “I won’t say that judges are affected by the media… (if I say that) then you would say by reading (media reports), we are giving judgments.”

It is said by the common public that media nowadays is so much involved in publicising an offence committed by a particular person or giving its decision even before that person is tried in court for it, he said.

The judge said that media cannot go to such an extent. Sometimes witnesses are interviewed before they go to court, he said.

It is said that such a “media trial” is having an effect on the prosecution, he said.

“But as far as I am concerned, I would always go by facts. Every judge should go by the fact (like) what is the evidence before the court of the law and how the prosecution has proved the case,” he said.

Justice Naik added, “Judges don’t get influenced by media.”

In his address to the students, Naik, who is originally from Goa and later went to Mumbai for work, recalled the days when he began practising.

“I recollect during my days, the legal profession was not given importance. People used to think that it was not rewarding,” he said.

Those days, Justice Naik said, he did not have a telephone at home and would go to a public booth to make calls to his clients.

“One day, an attendant of the booth asked me ‘tumhala kahi miltay ka’ (do you get anything in this profession). This was the impression of the public (about the legal profession),” he said.

Naik said when he was studying law, most of his fellow students were employed with private firms or banks or government institutions.

“Law was considered a part-time study. After the introduction of the five-year law course, I can see students, who are serious, joining (the course) now. There are several ventures open to lawyers,” he said.

  • Published On Oct 9, 2023 at 12:21 AM IST

Join the community of 2M+ industry professionals

Subscribe to our newsletter to get latest insights & analysis.

Download ETLegalWorld App

  • Get Realtime updates
  • Save your favourite articles


Scan to download App



Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Next Post

Delhi HC asks Delhi govt to review cap on beneficiaries under Old Age Assistance Rules, ET LegalWorld | Court Practice News

Sun Oct 8 , 2023
The court also ordered a reevaluation of the eligibility criteria, which includes an annual family income of Rs 1 lakh, and suggested data-driven surveys to gauge the demand for the scheme and economic conditions. In the interim, it instructed the government to establish a transparent mechanism for real-time information about […]

You May Like

Breaking News