In a significant ruling on January 8, 2025, the Telangana High Court reaffirmed that when a parent, who is a lawful guardian, removes their child from the custody of the other parent, it does not amount to kidnapping under Section 137(2) of the Indian Penal Code (IPC). This decision underscores the legal principle that actions taken by a natural guardian concerning their child are not criminal offenses under the kidnapping statutes.
Background of the Case
The petitioner, a mother of two daughters, alleged that her husband had expelled her from their marital home in May 2023, compelling her to reside with her parents. She claimed that in June 2023, her husband took both daughters away without her consent. Despite her attempts to file a complaint, the local police station allegedly refused to register it. Consequently, she approached both the High Court and the Family Court seeking custody of her children.
In December 2023, the High Court, while hearing her habeas corpus petition, determined that the children's custody with the father did not constitute illegal detention and advised her to seek remedy through the Family Court. The Family Court granted her visitation rights; however, she contended that her husband did not comply with these orders. On one occasion, when she was permitted to meet her younger daughter, the child was reportedly distressed and unwilling to return to her father. Acting on her daughter's emotional state, the petitioner took her younger daughter with her. In response, her husband filed a kidnapping complaint against her.
Legal Proceedings and Judgment
Justice Juvvadi Sridevi presided over the case, referencing a 2023 judgment by the Bombay High Court, which held that a natural guardian taking their child does not constitute kidnapping. The court observed that since the petitioner is the natural mother and lawful guardian of the minor child, her actions did not fulfill the criteria for kidnapping under Section 137(2) of the IPC. Consequently, the court stayed all further proceedings against the petitioner in the FIR filed by her husband until February 13, 2025.
Legal Implications
Section 137(2) of the IPC stipulates that kidnapping from lawful guardianship is punishable by up to seven years of imprisonment and a fine. However, the law distinguishes between abduction by a stranger and actions taken by a natural guardian. The court's ruling emphasizes that a parent's act of taking their child, even from the other parent's custody, does not constitute kidnapping, provided they are a lawful guardian.
Conclusion
This judgment reinforces the legal understanding that parental actions concerning their children, within the bounds of lawful guardianship, are not criminal offenses under kidnapping laws. It highlights the importance of recognizing the rights and responsibilities of natural guardians in matters of child custody and underscores the necessity for parents to seek legal remedies through appropriate family courts rather than criminal proceedings.
0 Comments
Thank you for your response. It will help us to improve in the future.