Madras High Court Mandates TET Qualification for Teachers in Minority Educational Institutions

Introduction

In a significant ruling dated April 15, 2025, the Madras High Court declared that the Teachers Eligibility Test (TET) qualification is mandatory for all educational institutions, including minority institutions. This decision marks a departure from earlier judgments that exempted minority institutions from such requirements, emphasizing the government's authority to prescribe minimum educational qualifications for teachers.​

Background of the Case

The case originated from an appeal by the State against a prior order of the writ court. The writ court had held that TET qualification was not mandatory for teachers in minority institutions and directed the State's Education Department to provide monetary benefits to Bashiri, a teacher who sought promotion without possessing TET certification. Bashiri was appointed as a Secondary Grade Teacher in Al Ameen Urdu Tamil Muslim High School, a private aided minority school. She was promoted to BT Assistant (Tamil) in 2022 and retired in 2023. However, the District Educational Officer did not approve her promotion due to her lack of TET qualification, prompting her to seek legal recourse.​

Court's Analysis and Reasoning

The bench, comprising Justice J Nisha Banu and Justice S Srimathy, examined the legal provisions and precedents relevant to the case. The court emphasized that the government holds the power to prescribe minimum educational qualifications for teacher appointments, a power exercised through the appointment of the National Council for Teacher Education (NCTE) as the "Academic Authority." The NCTE has prescribed TET as one of the essential qualifications for teachers.​

The court referenced the judgments in the Pramati Educational and Cultural Trust case and the T.M.A. Pai Foundation case to support its conclusion. It stated:​

"Therefore, this Court after perusing the facts, provisions and by relying on the judgments rendered in Pramati's case and T.M.A.Pai Foundation case is of the considered opinion that the Government has power to prescribe minimum educational qualifications for teachers to be appointed in the educational institutions including minority institutions. The government had appointed NCTE as 'Academic Authority' to prescribe qualifications. And NCTE has prescribed TET as one of the qualifications. Therefore, TET qualification is applicable to all educational institutions including minority institutions also."​

Implications of the Ruling

This ruling has far-reaching implications for minority educational institutions in Tamil Nadu and potentially across India. By mandating TET qualification for all teachers, regardless of the institution's minority status, the court aims to standardize the quality of education and ensure that all students receive instruction from qualified educators.​

The decision also underscores the government's authority to set educational standards and qualifications, reinforcing the role of regulatory bodies like the NCTE in maintaining teaching quality. It may prompt minority institutions to reassess their hiring and promotion policies to align with the mandated qualifications.​

Contrasting Previous Judgments

The Madras High Court's current stance contrasts with its earlier rulings, where it held that TET qualification was not mandatory for teachers in minority institutions. In a 2022 judgment, the court reiterated that the prescription of TET qualification under the Right of Children to Free and Compulsory Education Act, 2009, was not applicable to minority institutions. The court had relied on the Supreme Court's decision in the Pramati Educational and Cultural Trust case to support this view.​

However, the recent ruling indicates a shift in judicial interpretation, emphasizing the government's overarching authority to prescribe qualifications for teachers in all educational institutions, including those run by minorities.

Conclusion

The Madras High Court's decision to mandate TET qualification for teachers in minority institutions marks a pivotal moment in the realm of educational regulation. By asserting the government's power to establish minimum educational qualifications, the court aims to uphold teaching standards and ensure quality education for all students. This ruling may influence future policies and judicial decisions concerning the balance between minority rights and regulatory standards in education.

​

Court Practice Community

WhatsApp Group Invite

Join WhatsApp Community