Madras High Court Ruling: Sexual Harassment as a Continuing Offence

 

In a landmark decision, the Madras High Court ruled that severe instances of sexual harassment at the workplace should be treated as a "continuing offence," exempting them from the six-month limitation period under the PoSH Act. Justice D Bharatha Chakravarthy emphasized that ongoing trauma and fear experienced by victims constitute continuous harassment, justifying a broader interpretation of the statute of limitations.

Context and Case Background

The ruling emerged from a case involving R Mohanakrishnan, a superintendent in the district police office of the Nilgiris district, who was accused of rape by a female colleague. The alleged incident occurred in April 2018, but the formal complaint was lodged with the police only in December 2022, which was then forwarded to the employer. This significant delay prompted the accused to challenge the Internal Complaints Committee (ICC) proceedings on the grounds of exceeding the statutory limitation period.

Judicial Reasoning

Justice Chakravarthy highlighted the dilemma faced by victims of sexual harassment, who often endure prolonged trauma and fear of secondary victimization, delaying their formal complaints. The judge noted that this continuous mental anguish caused by the harassment itself fits the definition of an ongoing offence. Therefore, in cases where the harassment is severe and causes lasting trauma, the limitation period should not apply. The court recognized that the victim's delay in reporting the incident stemmed from the constant fear and societal pressures, exacerbated by the public disclosure of her complaint without masking her identity.

Legal Implications and Procedural Adjustments

The court dismissed the petitioner's argument to quash the ICC's inquiry report based on the limitation period, stating that serious allegations such as rape or continuous molestation should be treated as ongoing offences. The court explained that every day the victim suffers from the trauma is a fresh cause of action, thus extending the timeline for lodging a complaint.

However, the court acknowledged procedural flaws in the ICC's inquiry, particularly the lack of opportunity for the petitioner to cross-examine all witnesses. To address this, Justice Chakravarthy ordered the reconstitution of the ICC with the same composition, directing it to address the petitioner's grievances regarding cross-examination, ensuring a fair and comprehensive investigation.

Broader Impact and Future Considerations

This ruling by the Madras High Court sets a significant precedent in the interpretation of the PoSH Act, emphasizing the importance of considering the continuous nature of trauma in sexual harassment cases. It underscores the need for sensitivity in handling such cases, recognizing the complex dynamics that victims face, including societal stigma and fear of retaliation.

The decision also highlights the necessity for organizations to ensure robust and fair procedures in their internal inquiries, providing adequate opportunities for both the complainant and the accused to present their cases. By extending the scope of what constitutes a continuing offence, the court's ruling aims to provide better protection and redressal mechanisms for victims of severe sexual harassment, encouraging them to come forward without the fear of procedural barriers.

In conclusion, the Madras High Court's ruling represents a progressive step in the judicial approach to sexual harassment at the workplace, aligning legal interpretations with the lived realities of victims. It reinforces the principle that justice should not be constrained by arbitrary limitations when ongoing trauma and fear persist, ensuring that victims have the opportunity to seek redress and that offenders are held accountable for their actions over an extended period. This landmark decision is likely to influence future cases and contribute to a more supportive legal framework for addressing sexual harassment in India. 

Court Practice Community

WhatsApp Group Invite

Join WhatsApp Community