Calcutta High Court Stays Suspension of Junior Doctors at RG Kar Medical College

The Calcutta High Court recently intervened in a matter involving the suspension and expulsion of approximately 51 junior doctors from RG Kar Medical College and Hospital. This decision came in light of allegations concerning a pervasive "threat culture" at the institution. The college has garnered attention following a tragic incident where a trainee doctor was brutally raped and murdered after completing her night duty, raising serious concerns about safety and the institutional environment for medical professionals.

Legal Proceedings and Allegations

The junior doctors challenged their suspensions, asserting that the actions taken against them were arbitrary and lacked legal grounding. The court examined whether the Special College Council Members, responsible for recommending the suspensions and expulsions, had the requisite authority to do so. Counsel for the petitioners argued that the Council's recommendations were merely advisory and did not hold the power to enforce such punitive measures without state intervention.

Court's Decision

Justice Kausik Chanda presided over the case and determined that the recommendations made by the Special College Council could not be implemented until a formal decision was rendered by the state government. The court emphasized the need for adherence to legal processes and the importance of due diligence before taking actions that could severely impact the careers of the junior doctors involved. The judge stated, "In view of the aforesaid, there is no scope to implement any of the resolutions as adopted by the Special College Council Members of R. G. Kar Medical College and Hospital on October 5, 2024, at this juncture."

Implications for Medical Professionals

The court's stay on the suspensions highlights significant issues surrounding the treatment of junior doctors in medical institutions, especially in contexts where allegations of misconduct or safety breaches arise. This ruling underscores the necessity for transparent processes and accountability in disciplinary actions taken by educational and medical authorities.

Next Steps

Following the stay of suspension, the matter is set to be reviewed by a regular bench after the vacation period. This will provide an opportunity for a comprehensive evaluation of the case, ensuring that the rights of the junior doctors are preserved while also addressing the underlying issues related to workplace safety and institutional culture.

This ruling not only sheds light on the specific incident at RG Kar Medical College but also serves as a broader commentary on the legal and ethical responsibilities of medical institutions in maintaining a safe and supportive environment for their staff.

Court Practice Community

WhatsApp Group Invite

Join WhatsApp Community