The Punjab and Haryana High Court upheld Panjab University’s decision to disqualify a law student for two years after he was caught using unauthorized notes during an examination. The student, pursuing a BA LL.B., argued for leniency, claiming the punishment would severely impact his career. However, the Court emphasized the ethical standards required in the legal profession, rejecting his plea.
Facts of the Case
In December 2023, the student was caught with incriminating handwritten material while appearing for a "Law of Contract" paper. Following a thorough inquiry, the University found him guilty under specific regulations of its academic code. Based on these findings, the student was barred from all examinations for two years.
Legal and Ethical Observations
Justice Jasgurpreet Singh Puri highlighted the noble and ethics-driven nature of the legal profession. Refusing to grant leniency, the Court remarked that students aspiring to become legal professionals must uphold integrity. The Court noted that the punishment was consistent with University regulations, leaving no scope for a reduced sentence.
Arguments and Court Ruling
The petitioner’s counsel argued that the disqualification duration was excessive and would jeopardize the student’s academic future. In contrast, the University’s counsel maintained that the disciplinary measures aligned with institutional policies and were appropriate given the misconduct. The Court sided with the University, affirming the decision.
Conclusion
The ruling reinforces the judiciary’s commitment to ethical standards in legal education, sending a strong message about academic integrity. The decision underscores the importance of adherence to rules in professional education, holding future legal practitioners accountable for their conduct.
0 Comments
Thank you for your response. It will help us to improve in the future.