On December 10, 2024, the Punjab and Haryana High Court made a significant decision in a custodial death case, directing the transfer of the investigation to the Central Bureau of Investigation (CBI). The case centers around the death of an individual named Dalbir Singh, who died in police custody under suspicious circumstances. This order was issued after a petition was filed, alleging serious lapses in the investigation conducted by the local police.
Background of the Case
Dalbir Singh, a resident of Moga, Punjab, was arrested by the police on charges of drug trafficking. According to the police, he was taken into custody for questioning regarding his involvement in the crime. However, Singh was found dead in police custody, and his family members raised concerns about the circumstances surrounding his death, alleging that he had been subjected to torture and that the police were responsible for his demise. The family contended that the death was not a natural one, as suggested by the police, but the result of custodial violence.
The initial probe by the local police did not reassure the family or the public about the transparency of the investigation. This led to a petition being filed in the Punjab and Haryana High Court, urging for an independent and impartial investigation into the matter.
Petition and Allegations of Inadequate Investigation
The petition, filed by Dalbir Singh’s family, sought the transfer of the investigation from the local police to a higher, independent agency such as the CBI. They alleged that the police had not conducted the investigation with the required level of seriousness and impartiality. Moreover, they pointed out several inconsistencies in the police’s version of events and the autopsy report, which raised suspicions about the actual cause of death.
The petitioners also argued that the involvement of local police in the investigation could lead to a conflict of interest, as it was the same force accused of being responsible for the custodial death. They emphasized the need for a fair and transparent inquiry to ensure justice for the deceased and his family.
The Court’s Order and Directions
The Punjab and Haryana High Court, after hearing the petition and reviewing the facts presented, agreed with the arguments put forth by the family. In its judgment, the Court observed that the local police’s investigation into the custodial death appeared insufficient and lacked the necessary transparency and thoroughness. Recognizing the gravity of the situation, the Court concluded that a fair investigation could only be ensured if the probe was transferred to an independent agency.
The Court directed the transfer of the investigation to the CBI, instructing the agency to take over the case immediately and conduct a fresh inquiry. The Court also directed that the CBI be given complete freedom to investigate the matter without any interference from the state authorities. In addition, the Court mandated that the CBI submit periodic reports on the progress of the investigation to ensure accountability and prevent any delays.
Implications of the Court's Decision
The Punjab and Haryana High Court’s decision marks a crucial moment in the fight for justice in cases of custodial deaths. The transfer of the investigation to the CBI is seen as a step toward ensuring a more transparent and unbiased probe, especially in cases where the police are accused of wrongdoing.
This order is expected to have broader implications for the handling of custodial deaths in India. It sends a strong message about the importance of independent investigations in such cases, particularly when there are allegations of police misconduct. The decision also highlights the role of the judiciary in upholding human rights and ensuring that justice is served, even when it involves the state apparatus.
In conclusion, the Punjab and Haryana High Court’s order to transfer the custodial death probe to the CBI is a significant development that emphasizes the need for transparency and fairness in investigations involving police actions. The outcome of this case could influence similar cases across India and may lead to greater scrutiny of police conduct in custodial deaths.
0 Comments
Thank you for your response. It will help us to improve in the future.