In a significant judgment, the Kerala High Court addressed the legal intricacies surrounding step-parent adoption, emphasizing the necessity of obtaining consent from the biological parent. The court clarified that the Central Adoption Resource Authority (CARA) does not possess the authority to waive this requirement, underscoring the substantive rights of biological parents in adoption proceedings.
Case Background
The case involved a child whose biological parents had divorced by mutual consent. Post-divorce, the mother was granted permanent custody, while the father retained interim custody rights. Subsequently, the mother remarried, and her new husband sought to adopt the child. However, the biological father objected to this adoption. The Child Welfare Committee (CWC) declined the adoption request due to the father's objections. In response, the mother and stepfather petitioned the Kerala High Court to overturn the CWC's decision and sought a directive for CARA to relax the adoption procedures, allowing the step-parent adoption without the biological father's consent.
Court's Analysis and Findings
Justice C.S. Dias presided over the case and examined the relevant provisions of the Juvenile Justice (Care and Protection of Children) Act and the Adoption Regulations of 2022, formulated by CARA under Section 58 of the Act. The court focused on Regulation 4, which pertains to the eligibility of a child from an earlier marriage for adoption by a step-parent when surrendered by a biological parent. Additionally, Regulation 55 specifically deals with step-parent adoption procedures.
The court observed that, according to these regulations, the child must be surrendered by the biological parent through a jointly executed consent letter with the step-parent, duly attested by witnesses. This process ensures that both the biological parent and the step-parent are in agreement regarding the adoption. The court emphasized that the consent of the biological parent is a substantive right that cannot be waived or relaxed by CARA. Such rights can only be adjudicated by a competent civil court. Allowing CARA to relax this requirement could lead to situations where a biological parent's custody rights are undermined without due process.
Implications of the Judgment
This ruling has significant implications for adoption laws and procedures in India. It reinforces the legal standing of biological parents in matters concerning the custody and adoption of their children. The judgment ensures that a biological parent's consent is indispensable in step-parent adoptions, thereby safeguarding their parental rights. Moreover, it delineates the boundaries of CARA's authority, clarifying that procedural aspects can be relaxed, but substantive rights, such as a biological parent's consent, remain inviolable.
The court's decision also highlights the importance of a balanced approach in adoption cases, ensuring that the rights of all parties, especially those of the biological parent and the child, are protected. By mandating the necessity of consent, the court aims to prevent potential misuse of adoption laws that could adversely affect the child's welfare and the biological parent's rights.
Conclusion
The Kerala High Court's judgment serves as a pivotal reference point in the realm of adoption laws, particularly concerning step-parent adoptions. It underscores the necessity of obtaining consent from biological parents, thereby protecting their substantive rights and ensuring that adoption procedures are conducted in a fair and just manner. This ruling not only clarifies the legal framework surrounding such adoptions but also reinforces the importance of safeguarding the rights and welfare of the child and the biological parent in adoption proceedings.
0 Comments
Thank you for your response. It will help us to improve in the future.