In a landmark decision, the Delhi High Court has directed the Government of Delhi to reconsider the premature release of a life convict who had previously violated parole conditions. The bench, comprising Justice Girish Kathpali, drew upon ancient Indian jurisprudence, specifically referencing Kautilya's Arthashastra, which emphasizes the importance of reformation in sentencing. The court also cited Emperor Ashoka's Vth pillar edict from the Delhi Topra, which notes that Ashoka had granted pardons to prisoners 25 times over a span of 26 years, highlighting the ancient tradition of mercy and rehabilitation in the criminal justice system.
The convict in question had been incarcerated for over 18 years without remission and more than 21 years with remission. He had committed a serious offense in 2001 and had been denied premature release multiple times due to his past misconduct, including jumping parole and re-arrest in two other criminal cases. However, the convict argued that his single instance of parole violation in 2010 should not overshadow his subsequent good conduct and the commendation certificates he had received over the past decade, reflecting his gradual reformation.
The High Court acknowledged the gravity of the convict's original offense but emphasized that the purpose of imprisonment is not solely punitive but also reformative. The court noted that the convict had shown significant improvement in his behavior over the years, and the earlier misconducts occurred many years ago. The bench observed that while every wrong deserves a consequence, every consequence must have a limit lest it becomes wrong in itself. The court further stated that the convict's long period of incarceration and his subsequent good conduct warranted a fresh consideration of his application for premature release.
This decision underscores the evolving approach of the judiciary towards sentencing and parole, moving from a purely deterrent and retributive model to one that incorporates elements of rehabilitation and reformation. By invoking ancient legal philosophies and emphasizing the importance of reformation, the Delhi High Court has set a precedent for a more humane and rehabilitative approach to criminal justice.
The court's directive to the government to reconsider the convict's premature release application is a significant step towards ensuring that the principles of justice and fairness are upheld, even for those who have committed serious offenses. It reflects a recognition that individuals have the capacity for change and that the ultimate goal of the criminal justice system should be the reformation and reintegration of offenders into society.
In conclusion, the Delhi High Court's decision is a progressive move that aligns with the principles of restorative justice and reflects a deep understanding of the rehabilitative potential of individuals. By drawing upon ancient legal wisdom and contemporary rehabilitative principles, the court has reaffirmed the importance of mercy, reformation, and the possibility of redemption in the criminal justice system.
0 Comments
Thank you for your response. It will help us to improve in the future.